AI Is Brilliant. But I Still Wouldn't Trust It With My Business Numbers.
A few years ago, if someone had told me I'd be talking to business owners about artificial intelligence, I'd probably have laughed......Now it's everywhere.
It's writing emails, creating social media posts, summarising meetings and helping businesses automate all sorts of everyday tasks. Used properly, AI can save an incredible amount of time.
I'm a fan of technology. We use it every day at PBT, but lately, I'm hearing more and more business owners asking a similar question:
"If AI can do all that, do I still need an accountant?"
My answer is always the same. Maybe less administration. Definitely not less expertise. Because while AI is excellent at processing information, your business numbers need more than processing. They need understanding.
The danger isn't that AI gets everything wrong
The biggest risk isn't usually that AI makes huge mistakes. It's that it can be confidently wrong in ways that look right and that's far more dangerous.
If you've ever used bookkeeping software, you'll know that it likes to "learn" from previous transactions and sometimes that's brilliant. Sometimes it decides a software subscription is office equipment, a director's expense is business travel, or a one-off purchase should be treated exactly like something completely different.
The numbers still balance, the reports still look professional but the information you're using to make decisions is no longer telling the correct story.
And that's before we even get into tax.
Numbers don't make decisions. People do.
One of the biggest misconceptions I see is the belief that accounting is about producing reports and it isn't. Accounting is about helping people make better decisions.
Let's say AI tells you your profit has dropped by 15%, that's useful information but it doesn't answer the important questions.
Why has it dropped?
Is it because costs have increased?
Have your prices stayed the same while suppliers have become more expensive?
Are you spending more on marketing?
Is one service generating less profit than another?
Have you simply had a quieter month than usual?
The answer determines what you do next and that answer rarely comes from a spreadsheet alone.
Your numbers only tell half the story
One thing AI doesn't understand particularly well is context, the reality behind the numbers. For example, imagine two businesses both make a profit of £100,000.
On paper they look identical.
But one owner wants to retire in three years. The other wants to double the size of the business.
One is carrying significant debt. The other has substantial cash reserves.
One is struggling with cashflow. The other isn't.
Suddenly those identical numbers mean completely different things and that's where advice matters. Good accountants don't just read reports, they understand the people behind them.
Tax is rarely as straightforward as people think.
If tax was simply a matter of following a checklist, everybody would do it themselves. The reality is that business owners make decisions every day that have tax implications.
Should you buy that new vehicle now or later?
Should you take money from the business as salary or dividends?
Does that expense qualify for tax relief?
Should you invest in equipment this financial year or wait?
The technical answer isn't always the same as the best commercial answer and that's where experience and judgement come in.
AI can explain the rules but it can't always apply them to your specific circumstances.
Here's what worries me most about AI-generated advice
The biggest concern isn't bookkeeping. It's business owners using AI as a substitute for professional advice. If you ask AI a marketing question and it gets something slightly wrong, life moves on. If you ask AI a tax question and it gets something slightly wrong, the consequences can be a lot more expensive.
The challenge is that AI sounds convincing. It presents answers with confidence but confidence and accuracy aren't the same thing. Especially when legislation changes regularly or when the answer depends on details you haven't provided.
The businesses that will benefit most from AI
Here's the interesting part.......I don't think the winners will be businesses that avoid AI. I think they'll be businesses that use it intelligently.
Use AI to take notes.
Use AI to draft emails.
Use AI to help organise information.
Use software to automate repetitive processes.
Use technology to save time.
But when it comes to understanding profitability, forecasting cashflow, making investment decisions, managing tax and planning for growth, don't outsource your judgement and don't outsource expertise.
The future isn't AI or accountants
It's AI and accountants.
Technology has transformed accounting over the past decade, and that's a good thing. We're faster, more efficient and able to spend less time on administration and more time helping clients understand what's actually happening in their businesses. Because most business owners don't need more data, they're already drowning in data........What they need is clarity.
They need someone to look beyond the numbers and answer the questions that really matter.
Is the business making enough money?
Is there enough cash in the bank?
Can I afford to hire?
Should I increase my prices?
Am I paying more tax than I need to?
That's where human experience still matters and despite everything AI can do, that's not changing anytime soon.
Final Thought
AI is an incredible tool.
But it's still just that: a tool.
A calculator is a tool.
Accounting software is a tool.
AI is a tool.
None of them replace judgement., none of them understand your ambitions and none of them care about your business as much as you do.
That's why, when it comes to your numbers, I'd always recommend using AI to support decisions, not make them. If you'd like a clearer understanding of your profitability, cash flow and tax position, get in touch with PBT. We'd be happy to help you turn numbers into better business decisions.
Author: Vicki Summersby
Share this post: